The Cost of Skipping Tenant Screening: How Bad Tenants Cause Major Maintenance Issues

For landlords, filling a vacant rental as quickly as possible is often a top priority. Some may even skip tenant background checks in an attempt to reduce vacancy time and keep rental income flowing. However, renting to the wrong tenant can be far more expensive than waiting a little longer for a qualified renter.

A bad tenant can lead to months of unpaid rent, excessive property damage, and legal disputes—all of which result in major financial losses and maintenance headaches.

This article will break down the real costs of skipping tenant screening and how tenant screening online helps landlords:

• Identify high-risk tenants before signing a lease
• Reduce maintenance headaches by choosing responsible renters
• Ensure their rental property remains in top condition

The Hidden Costs of Renting to the Wrong Tenant

Many landlords believe that skipping background checks will help them rent their properties faster. While this may be true in the short term, it can create long-term maintenance and financial problems.

1. Property Damage Beyond Normal Wear and Tear

Every rental unit experiences some level of normal wear and tear over time. However, irresponsible tenants can cause extensive damage that requires major repairs and renovations.

Common issues caused by high-risk renters include:

• Unreported plumbing leaks, leading to mold and structural damage
• Broken appliances due to improper use
• Stained carpets, holes in walls, and damaged flooring
• Pest infestations from poor cleaning habits

Example Scenario:
A landlord skips the tenant screening process and rents to someone with a history of property neglect. Within six months, the tenant fails to report a leaking bathroom pipe, resulting in water damage, mold growth, and thousands of dollars in repair costs.

If the tenant had been properly screened, the landlord might have noticed past maintenance complaints or lease violations and avoided the financial burden altogether.

2. Unpaid Rent & Eviction Costs

A bad tenant not only causes maintenance issues but can also fall behind on rent payments, creating even greater financial strain.

Skipping tenant background checks increases the risk of:

• Rent payment delays or complete non-payment
• Legal disputes over unpaid rent
• Costly evictions, court fees, and lost income

Evicting a tenant due to non-payment or lease violations can cost landlords thousands of dollars in legal fees and lost rental income.

3. Higher Tenant Turnover Rates

A bad tenant can cause frequent lease breaks, leading to higher turnover costs for landlords. The expenses associated with frequent vacancies include:

• Marketing and advertising costs to find new tenants
• Cleaning and repair fees between tenants
• Lost rental income during vacancy periods

When a tenant is screened properly, they are more likely to:

• Pay rent consistently
• Respect lease terms
• Stay longer, reducing turnover expenses

How Tenant Screening Online Prevents Maintenance Issues

Skipping tenant screening is a gamble that can result in expensive repairs, unpaid rent, and eviction complications. A thorough background check helps landlords avoid high-risk tenants and maintain their properties in excellent condition.

1. Identifying High-Risk Tenants Before Signing a Lease

A comprehensive tenant screening online process includes:

• Credit checks to assess financial responsibility
• Eviction history reports to identify past rental issues
• Background checks for lease violations and criminal records

Screening applicants before they move in helps landlords filter out tenants who may pose financial and maintenance risks.

2. Reducing Maintenance Headaches by Choosing Responsible Renters

A tenant with a good rental history is more likely to:

• Report maintenance issues early before they escalate
• Respect the property and follow lease agreements
• Take care of appliances and living spaces

Screening reports that include landlord references and rental history help identify tenants who have a track record of responsible property care.

3. Ensuring the Rental Property Remains in Top Condition

Landlords can use tenant screening online to evaluate how well a tenant:

• Maintains past rental properties
• Follows lease maintenance clauses
• Communicates with landlords about repairs and upkeep

By selecting responsible renters, landlords can reduce long-term maintenance costs and extend the lifespan of their rental property.

What to Look for in a Tenant Screening Report

1. Credit and Financial History

A tenant with a strong credit history and stable income is more likely to pay rent on time and take responsibility for any maintenance costs they are required to cover.

2. Rental History & Landlord References

Past landlord references can reveal whether a tenant:

• Paid rent consistently
• Left the rental in good condition
• Followed lease maintenance requirements

3. Eviction and Lease Violation Reports

An eviction history report provides insights into whether a tenant has:

• Been evicted for non-payment or property destruction
• Repeatedly violated lease terms
• A history of rental disputes with landlords

If a tenant has a pattern of evictions, it’s a major red flag that landlords should take seriously.

How LeaseRunner Helps Landlords Avoid Bad Tenants

1. Comprehensive Tenant Screening

LeaseRunner offers:

• Eviction history reports
• Credit and background checks
• Landlord reference verification

2. Fast and Reliable Screening Process

With instant online screening, landlords can:

• Receive screening reports quickly for faster leasing decisions
• Identify high-risk tenants before signing a lease
• Reduce costly maintenance and eviction risks

3. Pay-As-You-Go Pricing

LeaseRunner offers flexible pricing, allowing landlords to pay only for the reports they need.

Conclusion

Skipping tenant screening may seem like a way to fill vacancies quickly, but it can lead to major maintenance issues, unpaid rent, and eviction complications.

By using tenant screening online, landlords can:

• Identify high-risk tenants before signing a lease
• Reduce maintenance headaches by choosing responsible renters
• Ensure their rental property remains in top condition

With LeaseRunner’s screening tools, landlords can avoid costly mistakes, protect their investments, and secure responsible tenants.

‍

‍